The development of self-driving cars comes with promises of improving road safety and potentially saving lives. Companies like Waymo advocate that the current safety standards achieved by human drivers are inadequate, claiming that autonomous vehicles can significantly enhance safety. Elon Musk echoed this sentiment when introducing Teslaโs Cybercab, asserting that autonomous cars could be considerably safer than their human counterparts.
Statistics reveal that human error contributes significantly to road fatalities. In 2022, the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration recorded over 42,000 deaths in motor vehicle crashes in the U.S., with a substantial portion linked to speeding and alcohol. Autonomous vehicles, which are incapable of engaging in risky behavior such as driving under the influence or speeding due to impatience, have the advantage of advanced technology like 360-degree vision.
However, the promise of self-driving cars faces significant challenges. The bar for safety is set high because fatalities are relatively uncommon on the road. In 2022, the fatality rate per 100 million vehicle miles driven in the U.S. was just 1.33, remaining consistently close to 1 for several years. Waymoโs autonomous vehicles had only logged 33 million miles of driverless operation as of September of the previous year, a figure inadequate for a meaningful comparison in terms of fatality rates against human drivers.
Waymoโs record shows fewer incidents involving injuries and police-reported crashes compared to human drivers, suggesting a positive trend for less severe accidents. Nonetheless, safety experts express caution, noting that computer systems could fail uniformly, leading to widespread issues that differ from the individual failures associated with human drivers. Moreover, while automated vehicles lack human flaws like intoxication, they may also lack the intuitive judgment that humans display.
There are notable instances where self-driving cars have made unexpected errors. Incidents like a Waymo taxi repeatedly circling a parking lot with a perplexed passenger or collisions involving the same car with a stationary vehicle highlight concerns regarding the reliability of autonomous technology. A key incident involved a pedestrian being struck after being thrown into a self-driving vehicleโs path; subsequent investigations indicated that a vigilant human driver would have reacted differently.
Negative incidents tend to be more memorable than positive outcomes, which could undermine public confidence in self-driving technology. Surveys indicate a growing skepticism about autonomous vehicles, with a decline in trust among U.S. drivers from 14% in 2021 to 9% in 2024 and an increase in fear from 54% to 66%.
While companies in the self-driving sector aim to enhance safety, convincing the public to embrace this technology will be more challenging than anticipated.
photo credit: www.ft.com